Top 13 Most Haunted Houses in Connecticut

Connecticut’s history, marked by colonial-era struggles, disease epidemics, and private tragedies, has left behind a scene dotted with homes allegedly holding onto their somber past. These homes, once the scenes of life’s deepest sorrow, now carry reputations as some of the most genuinely haunted places in the state.

From smallpox deaths and familial curses to unexplained demonic activity, the history of these haunted houses in Connecticut is defined by the tragedies that unfolded within their walls. We examine the specific dark events that gave rise to their current reputations for paranormal phenomena.

Benton’s Homestead (Daniel Benton Homestead), Tolland

The list of the most haunted houses in Connecticut starts with the Benton Homestead, established in 1720, which was home to six generations of the same family. Its haunting is tied directly to a tragedy of disease and separation.

In 1776, a Revolutionary War soldier, Elisha Benton (grandson of the builder), returned home with smallpox, which he had contracted while a prisoner of the British. His fiancée, Jemima Barrows, nursed him but subsequently contracted the disease herself. Both died within weeks of each other.

Due to the era’s customs, the couple, though devoted, were buried in separate cemeteries because they were never formally married. Visitors report sudden cold drops and sightings of a young couple in 18th-century clothing, spirits tied to their tragic end. Footsteps and sighs are now said to echo between the rooms where they passed.

Why Do So Many Successful People Secretly Wear a Little Blue Eye?

---

Limited time offer: 28% OFF. For thousands of years, the Turkish Evil Eye has quietly guarded wearers from the unseen effects of jealousy and malice. This authentic blue glass amulet on a soft leather cord is the real thing – beautiful, powerful, and ready for you.

---

Claim Your Protection

Bush-Holley House, Cos Cob

This historic structure, built in the early 18th century, was once the site of a wealthy household and later a famous boarding house for artists. The darker history, often cited as the source of its haunting, involves the slaves who lived and died on the property.

Records indicate that an enslaved girl perished from disease in the wash house or attic area. The trauma and unrecorded life of this young girl are believed to be the root of the ghostly activity.

Screams and persistent crying, allegedly belonging to the enslaved girl, are reported to still emanate from the vicinity of the old wash house on the property after nightfall.

Eells-Stow House, Lisbon

The haunting of the Eells-Stow House is directly linked to the smallpox epidemic of the late 18th century. In 1769, Captain Stephen Stow, a prominent local figure, dedicated himself to caring for victims of the smallpox outbreak.

In his act of charity, he contracted the disease himself and died alongside those he was trying to save. His selfless death and the suffering of the sick and dying on or near the property are the alleged source of the paranormal activity.

Staff and visitors often feel a distinct sensation of an unseen person standing directly behind them, and the strong, medicinal scent of old herbs sometimes fills the air. All these make the Eells-Stow House one of the most haunted houses in Connecticut.

Glebe House, Woodbury

The Glebe House’s history is steeped in religious and political conflict, providing a dark source for its alleged haunting. One particular entity said to be active is an aggressive, male presence in the attic. This spirit is believed to be one of the men who conspired against an earlier owner, Reverend Marshall, due to his unpopular sermons and beliefs.

The aggression manifests physically; people report being scratched and shoved by an unseen force. Separately, the apparition of a former maid, typically seen in gray attire, is observed diligently cleaning empty rooms and halls, suggesting a servitude that continues beyond death.

Huguenot House, East Hartford

The specific tragic history of the Huguenot House, or Makens Bemont House (built in 1761), is less documented in terms of a single dramatic death. Still, its reputation for haunting began immediately following a significant disruption.

When the house was relocated and underwent major renovations in 1971, two distinct entities were seemingly agitated. “Benny” manifests as unexplained knocking and wall noises. At the same time, the “Blue Lady” walks the upstairs hallway at precisely 2 a.m.

Local lore suggests the Blue Lady may be Abigail Bemont, who died in the house from a disease, her spirit disturbed by the alterations to her former home.

The Forbidden Encyclopedia That Makes Every Ouija Session Ten Times More Dangerous

---

Limited-Time: Up to 49% OFF!

Angels, devils, nature spirits, ancestors, tricksters, and creator gods – all catalogued with their true names, powers, and protocols. Judika Illes created the definitive directory of the spirit realm that practitioners around the world swear by when they need to know exactly who (or what) just answered.

---

Enter the Spirit Realm →

John York Home, Haddam

The John York Home is tied to a specific, violent event involving romantic rivalry and honor. In the 1700s, two soldiers residing at the home engaged in a fatal duel. The confrontation was over the affection of the homeowner’s daughter, resulting in a dual death by violence.

The alleged haunting is a direct and repetitive manifestation of this bloodshed. Dark, inexplicable blood stains reportedly reappear on the original floorboards of the house, and visitors frequently hear the disembodied, angry voices of men arguing, eternally reliving the conflict that ended their lives.

Lindley Street House, Bridgeport

The dark history of the Lindley Street House is not tied to a distant death, but to a terrifying, chaotic outbreak of activity in 1974. The Goodin family, living in the small bungalow, became the center of a renowned poltergeist case.

Objects levitated, furniture flew violently across rooms, and the family was subjected to unexplained attacks. The horror was compounded when a demonic-sounding voice was heard speaking through the family cat, Sam.

The events involved police and became a major media spectacle, investigated by demonologists Ed and Lorraine Warren, marking it as a location of modern psychological and physical terror.

Mark Twain House, Hartford

The Mark Twain House, a beautiful mansion, is haunted by the deepest grief suffered by its most famous resident, Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain). The central tragedy of the home is the death of his beloved daughter, Susy Clemens.

Susy returned to the house in 1896 while her family was abroad and unexpectedly died of spinal meningitis at the age of 24. This death was an unspeakable disaster for Twain. Staff reported seeing a woman in white on the upstairs landing, believed to be Susy’s spirit.

Additionally, the laughter of children is sometimes heard in empty rooms, a sad echo of the family life that was tragically cut short.

Monte Cristo Cottage, New London

This was the childhood home of Pulitzer and Nobel Prize-winning playwright Eugene O’Neill. The cottage’s dark history is deeply personal, centered on the profound dysfunction and addiction of his family.

O’Neill’s mother, Mary Ellen “Ella” O’Neill, struggled severely with a morphine addiction that began after a difficult childbirth at home. Her restlessness, psychological suffering, and emotional pain are the source of the haunting.

Her spirit allegedly still walks the halls in a state of agitation, opening and closing doors on its own, and a distinctive, unsettling giggling sound is sometimes heard in the dark.

Ever Walk Into a Room and Instantly Feel Something Watching You?

---

Millions have used burning sage to force out unwanted energies and ghosts. This concentrated White Sage & Palo Santo spray does the same job in seconds – just a few spritzes instantly lifts stagnation, breaks attachments, and restores peace most people feel immediately.

---

Purify Your Home Now

Nathan Hale Homestead, Coventry

The haunting of the Hale Homestead is indirectly linked to one of America’s most famous military executions. Though Nathan Hale was hanged as a spy by the British in New York in 1776, his execution and subsequent unmarked grave represent a national tragedy that deeply affected his family, who lived here.

The house is allegedly haunted by his older brother, Joseph, who died in a British prison ship. Unexplained footsteps are frequently heard running across the attic floor, and doors are reported to slam violently when no living person is upstairs. The activity is seen as a restless energy tied to the Revolutionary War and the deaths suffered by the family.

Palmer-Warner House, Coventry

The Palmer-Warner House is connected to a series of 19th-century family tragedies that have left residual emotional energy. While specifics are sparse, the house carries a reputation for sorrow and untimely deaths that were common in the era.

The reported paranormal activity includes the movement of a rocking chair on its own, suggesting the presence of an unseen occupant. Most chillingly, the apparition of a small boy in old-fashioned clothes is seen staring out from the windows of the home, his presence a mournful reminder of the young lives lost within its walls.

Peter Thorp House, Weston

Built in the 1700s, the Peter Thorp House is haunted by its long history and the unknown deaths that occurred over the centuries. The discovery of 18th-century artifacts dug up in the yard by later residents seemed to trigger the supernatural activity. The haunting is characterized by an acute psychological discomfort.

Visitors frequently feel shadows following them from room to room. An overwhelming, pervasive feeling of being watched is the most common complaint inside the structure, suggesting the presence of old occupants whose connection to the land and home has never ended.

Snedeker House, Southington

The last entry in the list of the most haunted houses in Connecticut is the Snedeker House. The house has a terrifying history of use as a funeral home with a morgue in the basement. When the Snedeker family moved in 1986, they reportedly found macabre mortuary equipment left behind. The spirits, allegedly tied to the corpses and the death-processing environment, manifested as extreme demonic oppression.

The family experienced multiple instances of terrifying poltergeist activity and alleged sexual assaults by unseen forces, necessitating numerous exorcisms. This frightening episode of human suffering and demonic harassment formed the true basis for the book and film, “The Haunting in Connecticut.”